I just finished sobbing my way through the ending of Cutting for Stone, Abraham Verghese’s excellent – albeit a little heavy on the surgical details – novel about conjoined twins who were separated at birth, grew up in the compound of an Addis Ababa hospital, and eventually became physicians themselves. After fleeing Ethiopia in the wake of the coup that overthrew Emperor Haile Selassie, one of the brothers, Marion,lands in the Bronx, interning at a small, struggling hospital that appears to be populated only by countryless souls like himself, both staff and patients.
In a book full of wonderful observations about human nature,I found a particularly relevant AHA! moment that illuminated something that I have been trying to figure out for a long time: Why some people can tell every blond child in the room apart, but can’t seem to remember the name of the one black, Hispanic or Asian child among them.
So here’s what happens in the story: Marion, who is half Indian and half British, is in the operating room assisting one of his Indian colleagues, Deepak. A white doctor, in the Bronx to collect transplantable organs for his fancy Boston hospital, happens to enter, observes their work, and after asking the colleague’s name and several questions about the procedure, compliments him on his technique then leaves for his helicopter.
We worked in silence. At last, Deepak said, “He heard my name just once…and he was able to repeat it . . . In all my years here, no one’s been able to remember my name when I’m introduced. No one has bothered. They usually see us as types, not as individuals.”
Deepak summed it all up right there, in these four,profoundly moving sentences: the experience, the frustration, a clear explanation, and the joyous dignity of recognition.
From parents of color, I have heard many stories of failure to remember their names and those of their children, no matter how many times they’ve been introduced, an inability to recognize them outside of the context of school, an unwillingness to even try to pronounce correctly names not commonly found in the US, and a difficulty in matching children to parents. Similar tales come out of the workplace. Several have said to me, “We’re just not important to them.” Others see it as an effort to denigrate – note the etymology here – sort of like the use of “Boy” in times gone by that, well, it seems are not so gone after all.
The part about seeing people of color as types, rather than as individuals really hit home with me. I thought of the time when my daughter was in preschool. There were 13 in the afternoon program with her, two of them girls with brown skin and not much else on the lookalikescale. Almost three months into the school year, a mother, who I saw every day at drop-off and pick-up, came tome to offer some niceties about who she believed to be my daughter while using the other girl’s name. When I pointed out that she was probably referring to another child, she appeared completely dumbfounded and confused. She was certain that she had the name right. I had to break the news to her that there were in fact two brown-skinned girls in the class, and with them, lo-and-behold, two sets of brown-skinned parents. In three months, she had never noticed.
Surely, as we get older, it’s natural to forget names every once in a while, and to some extent, I think we are all guilty of looking at certain people – immigrants, people of color, whatever – as types. But that doesn’t make it OK. I know I’m straying into heavy moral and theological territory when I talk about recognizing the dignity of the individual, but hey, it’s a really good conceptand one that we as parents would do well to teach to our children, especially through our own actions.
Just last week, a mother at my daughter’s present school asked me how she was enjoying Upper School. I told her that mine was actually in fourth grade now. Oh dear, there was that same bewildered look that that preschool mom wore six years ago. Yes, she had me confused with someone else, and my daughter with another child, although I’m not sure whom; forget that neither the girls nor the mothers looked anything alike. In an effort to be fair, I guess I should give the woman credit for trying. Clearly, though, we can all stand to bother a heck of a lot more.